By Developers, For Developers

Historical errata for Software Estimation Without Guessing

PDF PgPaper PgTypeDescriptionFixed onComments
xvTYPO

Model-Based Estimation paragraph:

Direct comparison is the root of estimation, but it we’re going to…

2019-09-17
xviTYPO

Empire Enterprises section

Some of it handles the all of the corporation’s accounting processes.

2019-09-17
10TYPO

Reference [1] shows ‘url>’ at the end.

2019-09-17
27SUGGEST

“If we were talking about something repeatable,
then a 90% confidence level would indicate that 90% of the time the actual
would come in within the estimation.”
It appears to me, that a confidence level is not useful without a range.

Example for a useful statement: “I’m 90 % sure, that the work will take longer than 2 days but no more than 4 days Is”
Example for a useless statement: “I’m 90 % sure, that the work will take 3 days” (because the work will never take exactly 3 days).

2019-10-07When people are asking for an end date, they're rarely concerned with the work finishing early. That's why I use the word "within." The example statement would be "I'm 90% sure that the work will be finished within 3 days."
27ERROR

“ estimating at the 50% confidence level is more appropriate. This means that half the time we overestimate and half the time we underestimate.”
I’m neither a native speaker and nor an expert in statistics, so I may be wrong. It appears to me, that this is the definition for the 50th percentile, not a 50 % confidence level.

2019-10-07Yes, we want the actuals to be at the 50th percentile, so we estimate at the 50% confidence level.
27ERROR

»Since we don’t get to repeat the same software development project in the same circumstances to measure that, we’ll just treat that as a colloquial expression meaning “pretty sure.”«

I’m neither a native speaker nor an expert in statistics, so I might be wrong. It appears to me, that the confidence level tells something about repeated estimations, not only repeated development work. Isn’t the meaning of ”90% confidence level”: Of all the projects, for which an estimation was given with a 90% confidence level, the actual effort was inside the given range (!) 90% of the time.

2019-10-07It means that we're 90% confident of the estimate of this particular work. Other estimates of other work are not a factor.
113-1DEFER

Some of the burn chart images are in the wrong places.

2019-11-25This has been corrected for the next release.

Categories: